Frontlist | Netflix's 'Bridgerton' is leading a romance novel renaissance

on Feb 08, 2021

There's no question that Bridgerton, the saucy Regency-era Netflix series, has hit iconic status. In a few short weeks since its December 2020 release, it's become the most popular show in the platform's history and secured a shoo-in second season. It's also courted legions of devoted followers who delight in the show's frothy, yet culturally au courant portrayal of a bygone British era (and abs. They also like the abs).

The show has also been a big boon for romance novel lovers.

Bridgerton is based on a series of books by romance author Julia Quinn, and its popularity has rocketed the books back on to bestseller lists, sparking new interest in a complex and extremely influential genre.

Much like Netflix's The Queen's Gambit inspired more interest in the game of chess, the time seems ripe for a Bridgerton effect, a moment that changes the landscape of the romance industry like The Notebook, 50 Shades of Gray and other influential works have done in the past.

But what it will change, and who will stand to benefit, is a story that's yet to be written.

Uncertain times have turned everyone into a romantic

Romance is having a moment. It's trendy to swoon, Tessa Dare, a bestselling author of historical romance, tells CNN. She says it's been thrilling to watch Bridgerton become a worldwide phenomenon and prove what millions of romance readers already know: These kinds of stories are for everyone.

Love, sex, and relationships are universally compelling themes, Dare says.

They're also profitable ones. A spokeswoman from Avon, the imprint that publishes the Bridgerton novels, told CNN sales of the original eight Bridgerton books have increased exponentially since the premiere of the show.

The eight books in the original Bridgerton series by Julia Quinn.

It's no surprise that such ultra-romantic, ultra-sensual stuff is topping bestseller lists and breaking streaming records. In fact, it's just business as usual.

Romance is the genre that funds the rest of publishing. That's the honest truth, says award- winning contemporary and paranormal romance author Suleikha Snyder. Romance holds up the rest of the publishing industry while also empowering readers emotionally.

Romance sales consistently make up a commanding share of the publishing industry. And during the pandemic, romance e-reader titles have seen a huge boost, probably for the same reason Bridgerton has resonated with audiences. When everything is bad and nothing makes sense, it's nice to be able to bury oneself, ostrich-like, in some good old escapism.

The past year has been so difficult for everyone. Collectively, we needed a mass infusion of joy, Dare says. If the world can agree on nothing else, at least 63 million households can celebrate the Duke of Hastings' perfectly arched eyebrow.

Bridgerton could woo new romance readers

Despite being a thriving and evolving genre, outsiders often view romance novels with disdain. Every time a series like Bridgerton gains a cultural foothold, some of that stigma falls away. The effect can be a win-win, attracting more readers to the romance fold, and emboldening longtime fans, who may have hid their passion, to share more about the genre they love.

Growing up, we had that image of cheesy novels you pick up at the grocery store, and people have held on to that idea says Roni Loren, a bestselling contemporary romance author. Seeing the popularity of 'Bridgerton' legitimizes the genre to some people. It gives people permission to start checking out things in the romance novel section.

Phoebe Dynevor as Daphne Bridgerton and Regé-Jean Page as Simon, the Duke of Hastings in Bridgerton.

Why, exactly, romance writers and readers continue to contend with these assumptions is a thorny question.

Sexism, Tessa Dare says, simply. Society is primed to view anything produced by women for women as lesser, and there's always been an assumption that romance is frivolous, poorly written, and holds little appeal for men. Bridgerton's success is proving all those assumptions false.

'Bridgerton's' intimacy coordinator's work not as sexy as you'd think

Just like in the books, there are parts of the Bridgerton show that are, ahem, spicy to say the least. (Episode 6. It's Episode 6. You're welcome.) There's even some actual bodice-ripping. And much has been written about how the series, like most romance novels, is formed purely from the female gaze: The women are best friends, family, rivals and sharp schemers. The men, though complex in their own way, are everything someone could want in a partner: Caring, witty, respectful, and well, very hot.

Across social media, people are having fun posting their reactions to some of the steamier scenes -- sometimes with nothing more than a knowing face or a few verklempt little noises.

I watch 'Bridgerton' for the plot, another popular meme says, followed by various photos of the sexy male leads, labeled: The plot.

How often do women get something like this, of sexual and emotional enjoyment especially tailored for them? Through generations of Playboy covers, Michael Bay movies and male-dominated media, romance novels have provided just that: A haven for women to explore their sexuality, their agency, and what it means to be loved and desired.

That kind of value can't be tagged with a dollar sign, and when social media is alight with people joking and sharing their saucy romance opinions, it's not just boosting a bottom line. It's revealing the genre's true impact, and inviting others to bask in the softly-lit glow.

New eyes on romance puts inclusivity in the spotlight

However, that glow doesn't shine evenly on all experiences, and when it comes to inclusivity, Bridgerton occupies a curious spot. From the outset, the show captured attention because of its diverse cast, including a Black leading man, a Black queen, and people of color in all kinds of roles, big and small. This is a departure from Quinn's novels, which give no indication of race and, like so many Regency-era novels, are set against the very white background of 19th century London high society.

Golda Rosheuvel as Queen Charlotte in Bridgerton

So while Bridgerton, the TV series, provides an inclusive experience to its fans, that level of representation doesn't carry over into the romance world as it stands. While there are sparks of new interest in the industry, writers are hopeful that the show's success will prompt readers to explore a wider range of romance stories.

We welcome new readers via 'Bridgerton' with open arms, Suliekha Snyder says. But the sticking point with the 'rising tide lifts all boats' philosophy is that sometimes it only lifts certain boats.

Will these new people only gravitate toward white Regency-era romance? Or will opening a Julia Quinn book and realizing the Duke is actually white make them seek out more diverse and inclusive books, thus widening the net?

When Snyder, who is South Asian, got into romance writing, she noticed a lot of books in the genre fetishized and othered South Asian people. That drove her to write stories with characters of South Asian heritage.

Snyder cautions against viewing this level of diversity in publishing as some sort of option, or a way to fill a special bookshelf at the store. It is, she points out, simply reality.

Diversity and inclusivity isn't just an educational tool. It's our lives. It's how we love, she says. And that's part of the struggle we've had over the past several decades. Just having to remind people that [authors of color] exist and are real and that our books have just as much mass appeal as a white author's.

Speaking of mass appeal, Bridgerton the TV show has also raised tantalizing questions about the popularity of inclusive media.

A romance novelist accused another writer of racism. The scandal is tearing the billion-dollar industry apart

I don't think of it as whether the show helps push the diversity conversation in romance forward, says author Alyssa Cole. But whether it wasn't the other way around

Cole, a contemporary, historical and sci-fi romance novelist, has won multiple awards for her books featuring Black, disabled and LGBTQ heros and heroines. Historically, romantic fiction by and featuring people outside of the white, heterosexual, abled populace has been shunned by big publishers. In recent years, even the Romance Writers Association, the genre's top organization, has been torn apart by accusations of prejudice.

In short, it has been a common assumption that stories like these don't sell.

But, Cole posits, the truth laid out by Bridgerton's success, and the future it may invite, are more promising.

At this point we've seen multiple romance adaptations with Black characters and characters of color added—would these shows have been as successful without a diverse cast? she asks. And if diversity is integral to an adaptation's success, why not adapt more books from authors of color?

In romance, everyone deserves a happy ending

Regé-Jean Page as Simon, the Duke of Hastings and Phoebe Dynevor as Daphne Bridgerton in Bridgerton.

If there really is going to be a Bridgerton effect in the romance industry, it's clear it has to be one that boosts writers and readers of all backgrounds. After all, the unifying theme of romance -- whether you're into werewolves, cybersex, Scots in kilts or women in stays -- is that everyone deserves a happy ending.

I think that's where the importance of inclusion is, having this space to safely navigate our identities while knowing it will end in a happily-ever-after, Snyder says. Queer readers, readers of color ... when we're reflected in the pages, we get to see our happily-ever-afters normalized. And that's radical. It shouldn't be. It should be commonplace. But we're not there yet, unfortunately.

These are the things to remember the next time someone dismisses romance as frivolous. Yes, there's sex. Yes, there is fun and escapism. And those things warrant no apologies.

The escapism of 'Bridgerton'

But romance means more to people than that.

It's very feminist. In a lot of romances, the woman is saving themselves. It's so pro consent -- it's our fantasy, that we want to be treated with respect, Roni Loren says.

Cole says another big draw is trust. Characters are often guarded due to past trauma. Part of their story is learning to trust someone, and that trust not being a mistake, she says.

One of the greatest fantasies is that you can show yourself -- all of yourself, including the bad stuff -- to a partner or friend, and trust that they will still love you. In a romance, that trust is always rewarded at the end.

When readers open a romance novel, they trust that something of themselves is going to be reflected in those pages, no matter who they are, who they love, or how they live.

And if a very sexy, very profitable Netflix show can pave the way for more of these stories to be told, then bring on the love. Source: CNN Entertainment